Can I Afford to Keep My House After Divorce?

1. Can I actually afford the monthly payments on one income? The mortgage is just the start — don't forget property taxes, homeowner's insurance, maintenance, and repairs. A common guideline is that housing costs should generally stay under 28-35% of your gross income, though this varies by situation.

2. Can I refinance the mortgage in my name alone? Most couples have a joint mortgage. To keep the house, you may need to refinance into your name only, which typically means qualifying on your income alone. If you can't qualify, keeping the house may not be feasible regardless of what the settlement says. Discuss your options with a mortgage professional.

3. What am I giving up to keep it? In many divorce settlements, keeping the house means giving up other assets of equivalent value — often retirement accounts or liquid savings. A $400,000 house is not the same as $400,000 in a 401(k). The house costs money to maintain, while the retirement account has the potential to grow (though returns are not guaranteed).

4. What would I net if I sold? After paying off the mortgage, real estate commissions, closing costs, and any repairs needed for sale, how much would you actually walk away with? Sometimes the equity is less than people expect. Commission rates and closing costs vary by location and market conditions.

5. Am I keeping it for the right reasons? Emotional attachment to the family home is natural, but financial professionals often cite it as one of the most common financial mistakes in divorce. If keeping the house means being cash-poor for years, it may not be worth it. Sometimes selling and downsizing could put you in a stronger financial position. Discuss the trade-offs with your financial advisor.

It often makes financial sense to keep the house if your housing costs are well within your post-divorce income, you have a low mortgage rate that would be expensive to replace, property values in your area are appreciating, you have children and stability is a priority, or you have sufficient other assets and don't need to trade the house for retirement savings.

Selling may be better if housing costs would consume more than 35% of your income, you'd need to sacrifice retirement savings to buy out your spouse's share, the house needs significant repairs or updates you can't afford, you'd be house-rich but cash-poor, or the proceeds from selling would give you a more secure financial foundation for the next chapter.

You Might Also Need